news-engine

← american_football

Kurtenbach’s 49ers-Rams prediction: Purdy looks sharp, but Niners’ trench issues too big to overcome

Times-Standard · Dieter Kurtenbach · 2026-09-10T14:32:50+00:00 · nguồn gốc

Not a single ounce of this makes sense. The NFL is dragging a regular-season game all the way to Australia. Fine. Whatever. We know how the league machine works. They won everyone over stateside, so now they need to grow beyond the U.S. But usually, when the league pulls a stunt like this, you get two random non-conference teams who can fly across the Pacific, treat it like a weird week-long study abroad program, accept the result, and move on. Instead, the shield, in its infinite wisdom, decided to burn a critical divisional clash. This is a game with massive, season-defining ramifications — not just for the bloodbath that is the top of the NFC West, but for the entire conference playoff picture when we’re counting tiebreakers in January. Outstanding work, Roger. Truly brilliant stuff. Absurdity aside, let’s dive into the actual football of this jet-lagged circus — because as farcical as the setting is, the tape and the stakes are dead serious. Player to Watch Nobody in red and gold did more for themselves over the last month-plus than James Thompson. And nobody in a San Francisco uniform is about to be tossed into deeper, more unforgiving waters relative to where they stood back in May. With Alfred Collins out for the year with a torn meniscus, the 49ers’ interior depth chart was essentially reduced to ashes. San Francisco enters Week 1 carrying two true nose tackles on the 53-man roster: C.J. West, who spent August delivering an erratic, dizzying rollercoaster of a preseason, and Thompson, an undrafted free agent from Illinois who looks like an offensive tackle but who played so well — displaying heavy hands and an uncanny ability to find leverage — that he leapfrogged from fourth-string camp body to arguably DT1. Thompson’s ability to anchor against the run remains entirely unproven at true NFL speed. We’re about to find out if the fairy-tale summer translates to reality, because if he can’t hold the point of attack and West’s volatility continues the Niners’ defensive foundation crumbles immediately. Player to Watch Out For Who aren’t you watching out for on this Rams roster? Let’s bypass the headliners and go a layer deeper. The name you need circled in red ink is Braden Fiske. The 2024 second-rounder out of Florida State is already blossoming into one of the most disruptive interior presences in football. He’s routinely overshadowed because the Rams’ defensive front is a comic-book lineup: Poona Ford plugging gaps, Kobie Turner wrecking pockets, Byron Young, an ascending Josiah Stewart entering year two, and Myles Garrett arriving via blockbuster trade from Cleveland. Oh, and Aaron Donald is back in the building too, though he will still be in Los Angeles when this game happens. That absence opens the door for Fiske to command heavy snaps — and he has the get-off and violence to turn the 49ers’ already fragile left guard situation into an outright disaster. Yes, the Niners’ young guards — Connor Colby and Carver Willis — are avoiding one of the all-time greats, but it will be anything but an easy day with Donald stateside. Trench Battle The 49ers are down bad on the edge. While they have functional pieces on the strong side —even factoring in Sam Okuayinonu’s banged-up status — there is exactly one bona fide, reliable pass rusher walking that sideline: Nick Bosa. Yes, rookie Romello Height flashed promise during camp, but recent injuries make him even more of a wildcard for Sunday. It’s kind of just Bosa. And coming off his third ACL reconstruction, he has barely practiced and hasn’t seen live game action since Week 3 of last season. How much burst does Bosa actually have right now? Remember: even under totally different circumstances during his 2023 holdout, Bosa took nearly two months to resemble an All-Pro after missing camp. The timeline here isn’t much different. Alaric Jackson and Warren McClendon Jr. are solid, competent tackles, not All-Pros. The runway is clear for Bosa to win early and wreck third downs — if his knee is ready to play along. That’s a big “if.” Tactical Showdown I could wax poetic about Kyle Shanahan deploying 12 and 22 personnel with George Kittle back. I could map out De’Zhaun Stribling’s inline blocking alignments or dissect Christian McCaffrey attacking Los Angeles’ shaky linebacker corps. None of it matters. The fine folks in Melbourne are about to witness the most primal reality of this incredible sport: can you run the ball, and can you stop the run? San Francisco couldn’t run it effectively last year. That should improve this year, but testing that theory against this Rams front in Week 1 might not show it. The real crisis sits on the other side of the ball. Sean McVay runs “Duo” — interior double teams designed to displace defensive tackles and dare linebackers to fill — at a league-leading clip, more than 40 percent. And McVay will call it until you prove you can stop it. He’s pragmatic like that. So when your interior defense hinges on an untested rookie free agent and an inconsistent late-round pick at the point, expecting anything other than a relentless diet of Duo is pure delusion. The Rams will run it 40 straight times between the tackles without an ounce of shame. That’s only slightly hyperbole. In the preseason, opposing fronts washed 49ers defensive tackles backward by distances that rivaled the flight from SFO to Melbourne, often using Duo blocking. If Thompson and West can’t hold their ground, the Rams will board their chartered flight home 24 hours after landing with a divisional win in their carry-on. Don’t Be Surprised IfGeorge Kittle walking onto a football field roughly eight months removed from a torn Achilles is borderline medical witchcraft. But let’s deal in reality: asking him to instantly be the league’s premier two-way tight end on day one is asking too much. Expect Shanahan to treat Kittle as a specialized weapon. Remember the 2025 game against Atlanta, when Kittle was nursing a hamstring injury and played almost strictly as a designated run blocker? He was dominant, because he’s a great run blocker and the defense still had to respect the threat of his route-running, meaning they couldn’t throw multiple bodies at him. The Rams must honor Kittle’s presence regardless of what his body can actually handle. If Kittle is deployed primarily as an inline mauler, expect Jake Tonges to soak up snaps and targets in heavy two-tight-end-personnel packages. If Kittle is used strictly as a decoy or pass-catcher down the seam, expect Luke Farrell to handle the dirty work, or for Shanahan to spread things out in 11 personnel. Shanahan usually prefers to ease into his offensive bag over the first month of the season, but Kittle’s physical limitations might ironically force the offense into the kind of hyper-specific, extreme looks you see late in the season from the jump. That could catch the Rams off balance. One More ThingNiners defensive coordinator Raheem Morris will have surely watched both the Panthers-Rams matchups from last year, looking to steal Panthers’ defensive coordinator (and former Rams and Morris assistant) Ejiro Evero’s tricks that beat the LA once and almost beat them in the playoffs. If that, indeed, happened, expect the Niners to blitz more weak-side defenders that aren’t actually pass-rushers — think defensive backs, safeties, and off-ball linebackers. Do the Niners have the players to best execute this? Is Jaden Dugger ready to play at the NFL level as a linebacker? Is Garrett Wallow really a better option? Can Upton Stout hold up in the run game? The Niners’ questions on the interior and the tactical demands that come with the Rams’ multiple-tight end looks put more pressure on perimeter players to make plays in this contest. I’m fascinated to see who rises to the occasion. Final Score PredictionMuch will be made of the logistical madness of both teams’ travel to Australia. The Rams are treating this like a military raid — landing just hours before kickoff, bypassing the body-clock adjustment entirely, and then flying straight out. Frankly, it doesn’t seem as if they care if they win or lose. The 49ers took the traditional route, acclimatizing to Australian time — a decision that might bite them when they return home, but theoretically gives them fresher legs this Thursday/Friday. Brock Purdy looked razor-sharp in August and should carry that rhythm over. Mike Evans and Stribling will find plays downfield, even against a revamped Rams secondary, and McCaffrey should be heavily featured through the air. But the trenches will tell the real story. The 49ers’ interior offensive line is walking into a buzzsaw against Fiske and that Rams front, and when Los Angeles has the ball, Kyren Williams and Blake Corum will likely churn out 60 to 80 more yards on the ground than San Francisco’s backfield can manage. The Rams are the more likely team to convert third downs, they boast the far more terrifying pass rush, and have an offensive scheme tailored to exploit the 49ers’ glaring weakness at nose tackle (amongst many other positions). Unless circadian rhythms win this game by themselves, Los Angeles takes the opener. Rams 27, 49ers 20